Wednesday, January 25, 2012

What's Sauce for the Goose May Not Be Sauce for the Gander

Avastin has been in the news a lot lately, and most of the press has been negative.  In November, the FDA revoked its approval of Avastin to treat newly diagnosed metastatic breast cancer.  Then, in December, Genentech, who manufactures Avastin, announced it would not seek FDA approval for the treatment of ovarian cancer, based on studies showing an improvement in progression-free survival but not overall survival.  Of course, whether Avastin helps women with ovarian cancer remains a controversial question, depending how you value progression-free survival. Compare this report with this one, for example. 


In tomorrow's New England Journal of Medicine, there are two reports of clinical trials evaluating Avastin for patients with newly diagnosed HER2-negative breast cancer.  In both this study and this one, women with newly diagnosed breast cancer were given chemotherapy with or without Avastin.  The women with HER2-negative tumors had a higher rate of "pathological complete response" if they received Avastin.  "Pathologic complete response" means that when it was time for surgery, not living tumor could be found.  Women with a "pathologic complete response" tend to live longer than women who do not respond as well.


What does all this mean?  Will these studies "reignite the debate" about Avastin in breast cancer?  I guess that depends on who is doing the debating.  I think the role of Avastin in breast cancer, indeed the role of Avastin in treating any cancer, remains unclear.  In the end, I believe it will be shown that Avastin helps some cancer patients and not others, and it will all depend on the biology of each tumor type.  Clearly, not all breast cancer is the same, and breast cancer is not the same as ovarian cancer, let alone osteosarcoma or lymphoma.  Today's studies simply reinforce the fallacy of extrapolating from one tumor type to another.  A drug may be very helpful for one type of cancer, and useless for another.


That's why we do clinical trials like this one, sponsored by St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, in which we are participating, trying to see if Avastin helps osteosarcoma patients.

These studies do raise another important point, which I will discuss very soon.  These studies relied on a "surrogate end point."  That is, the studies were designed to see an effect on "pathologic complete response," but only because that is thought to correspond with improved overall survival.  Only time will tell whether the women who received Avastin do actually live longer.

More to come...

Related Posts:
My name is FDA, and I approve of this message
Yes, we have no...Zofran?
Access to Experimental Drugs for Dying Patients

37 comments:

Noah Berkowitz said...

Such an informative blog, you somehow increase my knowledge about ovarian cancer. I really appreciate your post.

Kels Anne said...

Hello, I just started a blog.. I am trying to start a fundraiser/charity type of thing.. I am not sure what to call it, cause i am not 100% sure on what I would like to do.. Basically i have two passions. kids (with cancer) and music. :) So I am trying to figure it out. You can check out how it all began on my blog.. hope to hear from you soon!

Meagan said...

Interesting post. I definitely agree it does depend on each individual case, specifically. But I do hope it can be used to treat some types of cancer! Thats great news :)

Suji said...

I also agree with Meagan. I think the effectiveness of any drug depends on the nature or severity of the disease acquired by an individual.

Indore Hospital said...


doctorhelp.co.in is a medical web portal for everyone looking for any kind of medical Help from top Hospital. Doctor Help has been created with a view to help you find more about your medical problem and correlated Hospital before you go and select your Hospital.
Indore Hospital

Anonymous said...

Hi All,

Good articles

It's a great way to get a clean, permission-based list to which you can market. Doctors Email List is basically using emails to put across the services or using emails as a marketing tool to sell your product.
we have the most high-value; low-cost email and direct mailing lists available on the web today.

Benefits of B2B Marketing Leads
Pegasi Media Group

·Earning higher ROI through cost-effective email marketing
·Increasing website traffic
·Expand the scope of your email marketing campaigns
·Save money by reducing direct mail expenditures

(302) 803 5211
sales@pegasimediagroup.com

Unknown said...

drfredspirituraltemple@yahoo.com)) my dear readers around the globe, it is a great privilege to tell you about this great man who helped me over come the tragedy in my relationship, and how his herbal medicine help me too. My relationship became so complicated to a stage that I was scared of losing my wife to another, lasting long in bed was a problem and I knew deep down in my that my wife was not happy about it. Sometimes when I asked for sex the way she would act before the sex I noticed it was because I was not satisfying her, when she needed it more I hard already come and it was not the best. So I needed to find solution that was how I came in contact with DR FRED he really changed my sex life and ever since then life has been fun because my wife now love me more than she used to, all thanks to DR FRED for this great thing he did for me.. If you ever need help of any kind sickness like DIABETES.. HERPES.. you can visit DR FRED temple for solution ((drfredspirituraltemple@gmail.com)) or what's app +2348158839763

fitnesshealthforever said...

Thanks you and I admire you to have the courage the talk about this,This was a very meaningful post for me.Thank you.
Forever Protein Bar


WeRStupid said...

Thanks you and I admire you to have the courage the talk about this,This was a very meaningful post for me.

Check my website WeRStupid

Only my fitness said...

thanks for the information
fitness tips in hindi

MATINA said...

I was diagnosed as HEPATITIS B carrier in 2013 with fibrosis of the
liver already present. I started on antiviral medications which
reduced the viral load initially. After a couple of years the virus
became resistant. I started on HEPATITIS B Herbal treatment from
ULTIMATE LIFE CLINIC (www.ultimatelifeclinic.com) in March, 2020. Their
treatment totally reversed the virus. I did another blood test after
the 6 months long treatment and tested negative to the virus. Amazing
treatment! This treatment is a breakthrough for all HBV carriers.

Elanie Smith said...

[url=https://buyrxsafe.com/aspadol-100mg]aspadol 100mg[/url]
tapentadol 100mg

skipperoo1 said...


Cenforce 100, is an erectile dysfunction medication. Cenforce 100mg tablet is often referred to as the "blue pill" for treating erectile dysfunction (ED). It allows the user to experience orgasm while experiencing sexual excitement. This is a fast and simple method of treating sexual dysfunction.

skipperoo1 said...


Vidalista 20mg, is a PDE-5 depletion medicine that aids in the suppression of erectile dysfunction symptoms. The primary goal of this medicine is to address any concerns that men may have during intercourse. It mostly acts by boosting blood flow to the phallus. Erectile dysfunction may be a serious issue in a man's life at any age.

skipperoo1 said...


fildena 100mg, is the ultimate answer for those who are experiencing sexual health difficulties such as sexual impotency. Erectile dysfunction is the most frequent condition among males worldwide. If you are still seeking a lasting solution to your problem, here is the place to be.

skipperoo1 said...

pain o soma (carisoprodol) is commonly used as a muscle relaxant. The medicine works by preventing pain sensations from being transmitted between the brain and nerves. Pain relievers such as Soma 500mg are required, as well as rest and physical rehabilitation.

Tapentadol, the main component in aspadol 100 mg tablets, is a narcotic pain medication that is also used to treat all sorts of moderate to severe pain.

medsplus said...

Cenforce 100mg is an erectile dysfunction medication. Cenforce tablet is often referred to as the "blue pill" for treating erectile dysfunction (ED). It allows the user to experience orgasm while experiencing sexual excitement.

Cenforce 150 is essentially an allopathic medicine containing Sildenafil Citrate as its key ingredient. The 150 mg dosage is available in the form of tablets, coming in 10 in a pack.

Vidalista 20mg is an extremely effective treatment for erectile dysfunction. Tadalafil is the synthetic ingredient in Vidalista that makes it a PDE5 inhibitor medication.

mike said...

buy cenforce 100mg, which allows you to have a hard erection without worrying about impeding blood flow or even having premature ejaculation. The ingredients in Cenforce are all-natural and are approved by the FDA. If you do not have any prescriptions to fill, this is a great way to increase your sex drive and stamina.



First of all, let's look at to buy vidalista 20mg,. The active ingredient inside is L-testosterone, which is also called the Luteinizing hormone. This is the hormone that men produce before they become sexually active. But after they become sexually active, the levels of L-testosterone drop significantly. This is where herbal supplements come into play.



This all comes down to a simple answer. When you want something that will help enhance your sexual experience, you need to try the safest and most effective male enhancement product on the market. buy fildena 100mg, is the safe, natural alternative to other male enhancement products. And as long as you take it according to the directions provided by the manufacturer, you will not have any adverse effects.

Genericshub said...

Aspadol 100mg (Tapentadol) tablet used to treat relieve moderate to severe short-term pain, enough to require opioid treatment and when other pain medicines did not work well enough or cannot be tolerated. It works in the brain to change how your body feels and responds to pain.


Prosoma 500mg (carisoprodol), also known as Soma. It is a muscle relaxant that reduces pain sensations between the nerves and the brain. Soma is used to treating bone and muscular disorders such as pain or injury, as well as rest and physical therapy.


Pain o Soma 500mg (carisoprodol) is a muscle relaxant that works by blocking pain signals between the nerves and the brain. Pain o Soma is used together with rest and physical therapy to treat skeletal muscle conditions such as pain or injury.


Tapaday 200mg Tablet is a medication used to treat moderate to severe acute pain. It treats many conditions such as headache, fever, menstrual pain, toothache, and cold, and it effectively eases pain when other treatments fail to relieve it.

pain management said...

Pain O Soma 500mg(carisoprodol) is a muscle relaxant that works by blocking pain signals between the nerves and the brain. Pain o Soma is used together with rest and physical therapy to treat skeletal muscle conditions such as pain or injury.

Pain Solution said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Elanie Smith said...

We are a distributor of general pills like- pain o soma 500mg | buy tapentadol online | prosoma 500mg | fildena 200 | cenforce 150 Click upon that to get more about that product. Thanks

medsplus said...


Vidalista 20mg is an extremely effective treatment for erectile dysfunction. Tadalafil is the synthetic ingredient in Vidalista that makes it a PDE5 inhibitor medication.

vidalista 80 is recommended by doctors for the treatment of erectile dysfunction (ED) or barrenness in men. Tadalafil is the active ingredient in Vidalista 80 mg, which is available in an 80mg strength.

Elanie Smith said...

I'm Elanie Smith from the USA and working as an Online pharmacist with buyrxsafe.com, We are a distributor of general pills like- tapaday 200 mg | buy tapentadol online | prosoma 500mg |fildena | cenforce Click upon that to get more about that product. Thanks

mike said...

Sometimes this condition results from a heart condition or heart valve disease. ED is most typical in men who are 45 years aged or older. cenforce 200, drugs are most effective when taken on an empty stomach an hour before sex.

Impotence or male ED can affect men of any age, sexual experience, body size, or ethnicity – albeit African American men are most in danger. The causes of impotence are often thanks to psychological or other medical conditions take cenforce 100,.

vidalista-20, drugs are to treat male erectile dysfunction. If you suffer from stress, rest can assist you to feel better and improve your male erectile dysfunction. If you’re unwell, you’ll crop on your caloric intake and increase your physical activity.

Lorigail said...

Fildena 100mg is a PDE5 inhibitor drug that can be used to treat Erectile Dysfunction (ED). Sildenafil Citrate is the chemical ingredient in this medicine. Generic Sildenafil Citrate and Generic Viagra are also known for the medicine.

Trustablepills said...

Oral administration of cenforce 200 is the single most practicable arrangement. Ideally, you want to take the capsules on an empty belly even though consuming a short meal is not massive trouble their specialist.

Finances Note said...

The Blog Article is the best platform to get updated about going on things here are posts passport for publix | online order mall | simple and great juicing tips | green house gasses effects to know more click upon that. Thanks

Genericshub said...

pain o soma 500mg (carisoprodol) is a muscle relaxant that works by blocking pain signals between the nerves and the brain. Pain O Soma is use together with rest and physical therapy to treat skeletal muscle conditions such as pain or injury.

aspadol 100mg (Tapentadol) is an adult pain reliever to treat moderate to severe acute pain. It is used to cure various ailments, including headaches, fevers, period discomfort, toothaches, and colds. When other therapies fail to heal your pain, it efficiently relieves it.

skipperoo1 said...


Pain O Soma 350mg (Carisoprodol), as the name implies, is a medication that relieves pain since Carisoprodol is its main chemical constituent. It is an over-the-counter medication intended to relieve skeletal muscle discomfort. It functions by lessening the brain's and the nerves' perception of pain.

Weed said...

Illustration: Give your clients what they need, not what you think they need. Many help entrepreneurs head into the commercial center and have no clue on the off chance that they offer an item or administration that the public needs.
Order Bud Online

Eastwood Chiropractor said...

A few explicit activities can help your back. Others plan to extend your back muscles tenderly.
Eastwood Chiropractor

Taylor said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
buyrxsafe said...

cenforce 100 is the most popular prescribed medicine by doctors for treating erectile dysfunction in men.

It is a popular alternative to Viagra and ensures the proper flow of blood to the male reproductive organ, aiding in a firm erection during sexual intercourse.

This medicine contains an active ingredient called sildenafil citrate that treats ED or impotence quickly.

PillSuppliers said...

sildenafil oral jelly 100mg kamagra It is a popular substitute for Viagra that guarantees normal blood flow to the male reproductive organ, resulting in a hard erection during sexual intercourse.

Taylor said...

Pain o soma 500mg (carisoprodol) is a muscle relaxant that works by blocking pain signals between the nerves and the brain. Pain O Soma is used together with rest and physical therapy to treat skeletal muscle conditions such as pain or injury.

CTI said...

Very informative! Thanks.

Nursing leadership
Physician Burnout Treatment